Board Thread:Wiki discussion/@comment-18014300-20181025173429/@comment-18014300-20181111214918

Zero-ELEC wrote: I also don't believe that it's that important to match Wikipedia's standards. We don't control those but we control the ones here. I get your 3rd point, tho. I'm undecided so, I guess count this as abstain so far? I also wish to clarify that I understand that my argument doesn't preclude the possibility that this is a case where you may argue that we should deviate from Wikipedia in spite of respecting it as a standard. I know that that's probably what you were getting at instead of the points that some previous users have made where they displayed a complete disregard of wiki principles. So I don't wish to come across as dismissive of your point because I know you aren't like that latter group of people. :P

Vetinari wrote: Personally, I think the commas look messy but I'm from the Indiana Jones Wiki where "Indiana" is a state and a dog, and Cairo is the Egyptian capital, the city in Illinois and a person. "Cairo", "Cairo, United States of America" and "Cairo (individual)" together would make my teeth itch. ;) I think from your perspective that is a valid point. While I personally would not mind that, it's understandable how some people would think this seems like disambiguation formatting is all over the place.